Tidy.
Honest comparison · 2026

Tidy vs Hazel: which Mac auto-organizer should you buy?

Both apps make your Mac clean itself. They just believe in very different things — and one of them costs almost five times more.

Updated August 2026 · Written by the developer of Tidy — bias disclosed, honesty guaranteed.

The 20-second verdict: if you want deeply customized, folder-by-folder automation with AppleScript hooks and don't mind building rules for an afternoon, Hazel ($42) is the veteran power tool and still excellent. If you want your screenshots, installers and Downloads handled the minute you install it — with on-device AI renaming and a one-time $9 price — that's exactly what Tidy was built for.

Side by side

TidyHazel
Price$9 once, lifetime updates$42 once (major upgrades paid)
Time to first result~2 minutes, zero configYou build every rule yourself
Create rules in plain language (AI)Yes — on-device, macOS 26No
Rename files from their contentYes — OCR on images & scanned PDFs, plus free-form AI naming promptsPattern/token renaming; matches indexed text, no OCR of images
Dry-run mode (preview before anything moves)YesNo
Ejects .dmg + trashes the installerYes, automaticPartially (App Sweep is for uninstalling)
Watch any folder, deeply nestedDownloads (any folder you pick) + Desktop; never enters subfolders by designYes — any folders, recursive
AppleScript / shell hooksNoYes
Interface languagesEnglish · Spanish · GermanEnglish
Safety designNever deletes; Trash-first; only touches new files; run-level undoDepends on the rules you write
Privacy100% on-device, no account, its only network call is the update checkAlso fully local

Where Hazel wins — genuinely

If you read those three points and felt excitement rather than exhaustion, buy Hazel — sincerely.

Where Tidy wins

★★★★★
„Aufräumen kann so einfach sein.“
Independent 5/5-star review — wattblicker.de (Germany)
Read the full review →

Frequently asked

Is Tidy a full replacement for Hazel?

For most people who want Downloads and Desktop to organize themselves: yes. If you rely on deeply nested rules, AppleScript hooks or many watched folders, Hazel remains the power tool.

Can I use both together?

Yes — several users do. Keep Hazel for complex workflows and let Tidy own screenshots, installers and Downloads. Just don't point both at the same folder with conflicting rules.

Does Tidy run on Intel Macs?

Yes — universal app, macOS 14 or later. Only the optional AI features require Apple Intelligence (macOS 26).

Is $9 really the whole price?

Yes. One payment, lifetime updates, 14-day money-back guarantee, no subscription.

Try the $9 one

Install Tidy today and your Mac starts tidying itself before your coffee cools down.

Get Tidy — $9 once
One-time payment · 14-day guarantee · macOS 14+, Apple Silicon & Intel

Comparison based on publicly available pricing and features as of August 2026. Hazel is a trademark of Noodlesoft, LLC — a genuinely good app we respect; this page exists because people keep asking us for the differences. Corrections welcome at hola@tidymacapp.com.