Both apps make your Mac clean itself. They just believe in very different things — and one of them costs almost five times more.
Updated August 2026 · Written by the developer of Tidy — bias disclosed, honesty guaranteed.
| Tidy | Hazel | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $9 once, lifetime updates | $42 once (major upgrades paid) |
| Time to first result | ~2 minutes, zero config | You build every rule yourself |
| Create rules in plain language (AI) | Yes — on-device, macOS 26 | No |
| Rename files from their content | Yes, out of the box — OCR on images & scanned PDFs names the file for you, plus free-form AI naming prompts | Hazel 6 can OCR PDFs and images on-the-fly for rule matching, and captured tokens can be used in renames — powerful, but you build every pattern yourself |
| Dry-run mode (preview before anything moves) | Yes — the full plan of every move, before anything happens | Rule preview shows matching files; Hazel 6 added per-file Revert in Finder |
| Ejects .dmg + trashes the installer | Yes, automatic | Partially — a rule can trash old .dmg files, but ejecting the mounted volume needs a custom AppleScript |
| Watch any folder, deeply nested | Downloads (any folder you pick) + Desktop; never enters subfolders by design | Yes — any folders, recursive |
| AppleScript / shell hooks | No | Yes |
| Interface languages | English · Spanish · German | English |
| Safety design | Never deletes; Trash-first; only touches new files; run-level undo | Hazel 6 added Revert File (undo moves/renames from Finder); deletion behavior depends on the rules you write |
| Privacy | 100% on-device, no account, its only network call is the update check | Also fully local |
Updated August 14, 2026 — a MacRumors reader pointed out our Hazel column was written against an older Hazel and didn't credit Hazel 6's on-the-fly OCR matching and Revert File. He was right; the table above reflects the correction.
If you read those three points and felt excitement rather than exhaustion, buy Hazel — sincerely.
„Aufräumen kann so einfach sein.“
For most people who want Downloads and Desktop to organize themselves: yes. If you rely on deeply nested rules, AppleScript hooks or many watched folders, Hazel remains the power tool.
Yes — several users do. Keep Hazel for complex workflows and let Tidy own screenshots, installers and Downloads. Just don't point both at the same folder with conflicting rules.
Yes — universal app, macOS 14 or later. Only the optional AI features require Apple Intelligence (macOS 26).
Yes. One payment, lifetime updates, 14-day money-back guarantee, no subscription.
Install Tidy today and your Mac starts tidying itself before your coffee cools down.
Get Tidy — $9 onceComparison based on publicly available pricing and features as of August 2026. Hazel is a trademark of Noodlesoft, LLC — a genuinely good app we respect; this page exists because people keep asking us for the differences. Corrections welcome at hola@tidymacapp.com.
Also worth reading: Apple’s on-device model takes no images · The model stole a word · A Mac file organizer with no subscription